Relevant or irrelevant evidence?
Decide whether each piece of evidence actually supports the claim.
Loading practice…
Example: how to solve it
Read the claim and piece of evidence. Choose relevant if the evidence helps prove the claim, or irrelevant if it does not.
Ask: If this is true, does it give a reason to believe the claim?
Claim: Puzzle games can build problem-solving skills. Evidence: Many new video games cost more than $50.
irrelevant
The claim is: Puzzle games can build problem-solving skills.
Ask: if "Many new video games cost more than $50" is true, is that a reason to believe the claim?
No. It may be true, but it has nothing to do with whether the claim is right, so it is irrelevant.
Here it is solved: Claim: Puzzle games can build problem-solving skills. Evidence: Many new video games cost more than $50. → irrelevant