The Thanksgiving Count
Maya helps her grandfather count monarch butterflies and learns that a hard job is worth doing carefully. An original story for grade 3 (250 words) with numbered paragraphs, vocabulary notes, stop-and-think questions, text-dependent multiple choice, a two-part evidence question and a written response.
- Ask and answer questions about a story, referring to the text for answers RL.3.1
- Recount stories, including fables and folktales, and explain the central message, lesson or moral RL.3.2
- Describe characters' traits, motivations and feelings, and how their actions affect events RL.3.3
- Tell the meaning of words and phrases, including literal and nonliteral language RL.3.4
The Thanksgiving Count
Read the passage. Then turn the page and answer the questions.
The Thanksgiving Count
The morning after Thanksgiving, Grandpa woke Maya up before the sun. "Wear your warmest sweater," he said. "The butterflies are waiting."
Every year, Grandpa volunteered1 for the Thanksgiving monarch count at the grove near his house in Santa Cruz. This year, for the first time, Maya was old enough to help.
At the grove, the air smelled like eucalyptus2 and salt. Maya looked up. At first, all she saw were brown, dead-looking leaves hanging from the branches. Then a bit of sun hit the tree, and one of the leaves opened. It was orange.
"They're all butterflies," she whispered.
Grandpa handed her a clicker counter and a pair of binoculars3. "We can't count every single one," he explained. "So we count the butterflies in one small bunch. Then we figure out how many bunches look about the same size."
The Thanksgiving Count
Keep reading. Then turn the page and answer the questions.
The Thanksgiving Count (continued)
Maya counted the first bunch. Forty-two. She counted it again to be sure. Forty-five. Her neck hurt from looking up, and her fingers were cold. "Can't we just guess?" she asked.
"Scientists all over California are using our numbers," Grandpa said. "If we guess, they won't know if the monarchs are doing better or worse."
So Maya kept counting. She counted slowly and carefully, the way she checked her math homework. By lunchtime, she and Grandpa had counted more than six hundred monarchs. Grandpa wrote the number on his form and signed it. Then he handed the pen to Maya.
"Your name goes here too," he said. "You're a scientist now."
The Thanksgiving Count
Answer the questions. Use the text to help you.
- aGuessing would take too much time.
- bHe wants Maya to practice her math.
- cThe rules say children cannot guess.
- dScientists need correct numbers to know how the monarchs are doing.
- aThey count one bunch and then find bunches about the same size.
- bThey take a picture and count later.
- cThey ask other volunteers for their numbers.
- dThey count every butterfly one at a time.
- aTo show how the butterflies hide with their wings closed.
- bTo show that the butterflies are sick.
- cTo show that it is autumn.
- dTo explain why Grandpa is sad.
- aThanksgiving is the best holiday.
- bGrandparents always know best.
- cDoing a hard job carefully can make a real difference.
- dButterflies are hard to find in winter.
The Thanksgiving Count
Answer the questions. Use the text to help you.
- aresponsible
- bcareless
- cbored
- dfrightened
- a"'Can't we just guess?' she asked."
- b"She counted slowly and carefully, the way she checked her math homework."
- c"'They're all butterflies,' she whispered."
- d"Her neck hurt from looking up, and her fingers were cold."
The Thanksgiving Count
Answer the questions. Use the text to help you.
- Have you ever done a job that felt boring but turned out to matter? What happened?
- What makes someone a scientist? Is Maya a scientist? Explain.