Mamie Tape's Right to Learn
In 1884, a San Francisco school turned away an eight-year-old Chinese American girl. Her parents went to court. An original nonfiction text for grade 4 (325 words) with numbered paragraphs, vocabulary notes, stop-and-think questions, text-dependent multiple choice, a two-part evidence question and a written response.
- Find the main idea, explain how details support it, and summarize the text RI.4.2
- Explain events, procedures or ideas, including what happened and why RI.4.3
- Describe how a text is structured: time order, comparison, cause and effect, problem and solution RI.4.5
- Explain how an author uses reasons and evidence to support particular points in a text RI.4.8
Mamie Tape's Right to Learn
Read the passage. Then turn the page and answer the questions.
Mamie Tape's Right to Learn
In September 1884, a girl named Mamie Tape walked with her mother to the Spring Valley School in San Francisco. Mamie was eight years old. She had been born in San Francisco. She spoke English. She wanted to go to school with the other children in her neighborhood.
The principal refused to let her in. The reason was that Mamie's parents had been born in China.
At that time, many people in California treated Chinese immigrants and their families unfairly. California law said every child had the right to a free public education, but San Francisco schools would not admit1 Chinese American children.
Mamie's parents, Joseph and Mary Tape, decided to fight. They took the school to court. Their case was called Tape v. Hurley, after the principal, Jennie Hurley.
In January 1885, a judge ruled that Mamie had the right to attend public school. The school board appealed2 the decision to the California Supreme Court. In March 1885, the Supreme Court agreed: Mamie Tape, like every child in California, had a right to a public education.
Mamie Tape's Right to Learn
Keep reading. Then turn the page and answer the questions.
Mamie Tape's Right to Learn (continued)
It was a big victory3. But the state found a way around it. Lawmakers quickly passed a new law allowing cities to open separate schools for Chinese children. San Francisco opened one, and instead of letting Mamie into Spring Valley, the city told her to go there.
Mary Tape was furious. She wrote a powerful letter to the school board. In it, she asked how the board could punish a child simply for being of Chinese descent4, and she pointed out that her children dressed, talked and lived like the other children in the city.
Mamie went to the new separate school. Separate schools for Chinese children in San Francisco did not end for many years. But the Tapes' case helped establish that California's children had a right to be educated, and it became part of a long fight for equal schools that continued into the next century.
Mamie Tape's Right to Learn
Answer the questions. Use the text to help you.
- aSpring Valley School was the best school in San Francisco.
- bMamie Tape was born in China.
- cThe California Supreme Court met in 1885.
- dMamie Tape's family fought for her right to go to school, and their case mattered even though it did not end unfair treatment.
- aLawmakers passed a law allowing separate schools for Chinese children.
- bThe principal apologized.
- cAll schools in California closed.
- dMamie went to Spring Valley School.
- aThe state avoided following the spirit of the decision.
- bThe state walked around the court building.
- cThe state built a road around the school.
- dThe state agreed completely with the decision.
- aTo describe her neighborhood.
- bTo show where her school was.
- cTo show that the only reason she was turned away was her family's background.
- dTo explain how she learned English.
Mamie Tape's Right to Learn
Answer the questions. Use the text to help you.
- aThe case was important even though Mamie did not get into Spring Valley.
- bMamie never went to school.
- cThe case was a complete failure.
- dSeparate schools were fair.
- aThe principal refused to let her in.
- bBut the Tapes' case helped establish that California's children had a right to be educated, and it became part of a long fight for equal schools that continued into the next century.
- cMamie went to the new separate school.
- dMary Tape was furious.
- Why do you think Mary Tape wrote a letter to the school board?
- Why does it matter that every child has the right to go to school?