The Uniform Debate
Kiara has to argue for school uniforms, even though she is against them. A grade 5 reading comprehension story with questions and an answer key.
- Quote accurately from a story when explaining it and drawing inferences RL.5.1
- Find the theme from details in the text, including how characters respond to challenges; summarize RL.5.2
- Compare and contrast two characters, settings or events using specific details RL.5.3
- Describe how a narrator's or speaker's point of view affects how events are described RL.5.6
The Uniform Debate
Read the passage. Then turn the page and answer the questions.
The Uniform Debate Story
Ms. Thompson's fifth-grade class was holding its first debate. The question was “Should our school require uniforms?” Kiara was thrilled until Ms. Thompson read the teams. Kiara had to argue FOR uniforms. “But I hate the idea of uniforms!” Kiara said. “I like choosing my own clothes.” “That's exactly why I put you on that side,” Ms. Thompson said. “A good debater understands the other side's argument as well as her own.”
For a week, Kiara researched. She interviewed her neighbor, who taught at a school with uniforms. She read articles that said uniforms could save families money on clothes and make mornings less stressful. She found a survey where some students said they felt less pressure to wear expensive brands. She also found articles that disagreed, and she wrote down those arguments too, so she could answer them.
On debate day, Kiara's hands were cold, but her notes were ready. The other team, led by her best friend Marcus, argued that uniforms take away students' freedom to express themselves. Kiara answered, “Students can still express themselves through their ideas, their art and their writing. And families who can't afford the newest brands won't feel left out.”
When the debate ended, the class voted. Kiara's team won by two votes. Marcus shook her hand. “I thought you were against uniforms,” he whispered. “I still am, mostly,” Kiara whispered back. “But now I understand why some people want them.”
That night, she told her mom about it. “So did you change your mind?” Mom asked. Kiara thought for a long time. “Not exactly,” she said. “But I changed how I think about people who disagree with me.”
The Uniform Debate
Read the passage. Then answer the questions.
- alonger recess
- bhomework
- cschool lunches
- dschool uniforms
- ato help her understand the other side's argument
- bbecause Kiara liked uniforms
- cas a punishment
- dbecause Kiara asked
- aThey could save families money on clothes.
- bThey make students run faster.
- cTeachers like them.
- dThey are more colorful.
- aKiara's neighbor
- bKiara's mom
- cMarcus
- dMs. Thompson
- aso she could answer them during the debate
- bto show her mom
- cso she could switch teams
- dto give them to Marcus
The Uniform Debate
Read the passage. Then answer the questions.