The Proof
When Amara's poem wins the school contest, someone says she must have copied it. She has to decide how to answer. An original story for grade 5 (335 words) with numbered paragraphs, vocabulary notes, stop-and-think questions, text-dependent multiple choice, a two-part evidence question and a written response.
The Proof
Read the passage. Then turn the page and answer the questions.
The Proof
The poem was taped to the wall outside the library, with a blue ribbon next to it: First Place, Fifth Grade. Amara had read it to herself so many times that she knew it by heart. It was about her grandmother's kitchen in Lagos, the smell of pepper soup and the radio playing highlife1 music.
She was standing in front of it when she heard Tyler's voice behind her. "There's no way she wrote that. She probably copied it off the internet."
A couple of kids laughed. Amara's stomach dropped. She wanted to say something, but her throat had closed up. She walked away fast, before anyone could see her face.
That afternoon, Mr. Okonkwo, the librarian2, found her sitting at a back table with her head down. She told him what Tyler had said.
Mr. Okonkwo was quiet for a moment. Then he went to a shelf and came back with a thin book. On the cover was a drawing of a young woman with a pen in her hand. "Phillis Wheatley," he said. "Two hundred and fifty years ago, eighteen men questioned her because they didn't believe a young African woman could write poetry. She had to prove it."
The Proof
Keep reading. Then turn the page and answer the questions.
The Proof (continued)
"That's not fair," Amara said.
"No, it wasn't," he said. "And it isn't fair that you have to deal with this either. But you don't have to prove anything to Tyler. You know you wrote that poem. The question is what you want to do now."
Amara thought about it all night. In the morning, she had an answer.
When it was her turn to share at the class poetry reading, she stood up without notes. She recited3 her poem from memory, every word, looking straight at the class. Then she said, "I can tell you why I picked every word in it. Ask me anything."
The room was quiet. Then a girl in the front row raised her hand. "What's highlife music?"
Amara smiled. She told them. Tyler didn't say anything at all.
The Proof
Answer the questions. Use the text to help you.
- aPoetry contests are unfair to everyone.
- bLibrarians always know the right answer.
- cIt is better to stay quiet when people are rude.
- dConfidence in your own work can answer people who doubt you.
- aHe shows her she is not alone and lets her decide what to do.
- bHe writes a statement saying she wrote the poem.
- cHe reads her poem to the class himself.
- dHe tells Tyler to apologize to her.
- aShe suddenly felt upset and shocked.
- bShe was hungry.
- cShe felt sick from eating too fast.
- dShe dropped her lunch.
- aTo describe what Lagos is like.
- bTo show that Mr. Okonkwo likes old books.
- cTo connect Amara's experience to a long history of people being doubted.
- dTo explain how to write a poem.
The Proof
Answer the questions. Use the text to help you.
- aShe shows confidently that the poem is hers by reciting it and inviting questions.
- bShe writes a new poem about Tyler.
- cShe takes her poem off the wall.
- dShe asks the teacher to punish Tyler.
- a"That's not fair," Amara said.
- bThen she said, "I can tell you why I picked every word in it. Ask me anything."
- cShe walked away fast, before anyone could see her face.
- dAmara thought about it all night.
The Proof
Answer the questions. Use the text to help you.
- Why do you think people sometimes doubt others' work? What does that say about the doubter?
- Is Amara's answer better than arguing with Tyler? Why or why not?