The Laws of Hammurabi
Nearly 4,000 years ago, a Babylonian king carved 282 laws into stone for everyone to see. Were they fair? An original nonfiction text for grade 6 (430 words) with numbered paragraphs, vocabulary notes, stop-and-think questions, text-dependent multiple choice, a two-part evidence question and a written response.
- Find the central idea and how it is conveyed through details; summarize without opinions RI.6.2
- Analyze how a key person, event or idea is introduced, illustrated and elaborated RI.6.3
- Analyze how a sentence, paragraph, chapter or section fits into a text and develops its ideas RI.6.5
- Determine an author's point of view or purpose in a text and explain how it is conveyed RI.6.6
- Trace and evaluate the argument and claims in a text, telling supported claims from unsupported ones RI.6.8
The Laws of Hammurabi
Read the passage. Then turn the page and answer the questions.
The Laws of Hammurabi
In 1901, French archaeologists1 digging at the ancient city of Susa, in what is now Iran, found three large pieces of black stone. When they fit the pieces together, they had a pillar more than seven feet tall, covered from top to bottom in tiny wedge-shaped writing. It was one of the most important discoveries in the history of law.
The pillar had been carved around 1754 BCE for Hammurabi, the king of Babylon, a powerful city in Mesopotamia. At the top is a carving of Hammurabi standing before Shamash, the god of justice. Below it are 282 laws, along with a message from the king. He wrote that the laws were meant to make justice visible in the land, so that the strong would not oppress2 the weak.
Hammurabi was not the first ruler to make laws. But his code3 is one of the oldest and most complete sets of written laws ever found. Writing laws down was important. When laws exist only in a ruler's memory, they can change depending on who is being judged. When they are carved in stone and placed where people can see them, everyone can know the rules ahead of time.
The Laws of Hammurabi
Keep reading. Then turn the page and answer the questions.
The Laws of Hammurabi (continued)
Many of the laws dealt with everyday life: wages, rent, trade, marriage, farming and debts. One law said that if a storm destroyed a farmer's crop, he did not have to pay interest4 on his debts that year. Another said that if a builder built a house so badly that it collapsed and killed the owner, the builder would be put to death.
The code is most famous for the idea of "an eye for an eye." If a man destroyed another man's eye, his own eye would be destroyed. The punishment was meant to match the crime, not go beyond it.
But the laws were not the same for everyone. Babylonian society was divided into classes: free people of high rank, ordinary free people and enslaved people. If a man destroyed the eye of an ordinary person, he paid a fine in silver instead of losing his own eye. If the victim was enslaved, the fine was even smaller. Under Hammurabi's code, a person's worth depended on their place in society.
Today, the pillar stands in the Louvre Museum in Paris. Millions of visitors have looked up at it. Some see a harsh code full of cruel punishments. Others see an early and important step: the idea that laws should be written down, made public and applied by judges instead of by the anger of the moment. Both views are true.
The Laws of Hammurabi
Answer the questions. Use the text to help you.
- aHammurabi was the first person to make laws.
- bThe Louvre Museum has many visitors.
- cBabylon was a powerful city in Mesopotamia.
- dHammurabi's code was an important early written law, though it was unequal and harsh by today's standards.
- aThe punishment should be equal to the harm done, not worse.
- bPunishments should be decided by the victim.
- cOnly serious crimes should be punished.
- dEvery crime should be punished by death.
- aBy showing how the punishment for destroying an eye changed depending on the victim's class.
- bBy describing the carving of Shamash at the top.
- cBy listing laws about farming and debts.
- dBy explaining where the pillar was found.
- aIt describes what the Louvre Museum looks like.
- bIt repeats the information in paragraph 5.
- cIt complicates the idea of fairness introduced in the paragraphs before it.
- dIt explains how the pillar was carried to Susa.
The Laws of Hammurabi
Answer the questions. Use the text to help you.
- aIt was both harsh and an important step forward.
- bIt should be used in courts today.
- cIt was completely fair to everyone.
- dIt was cruel and has no value today.
- aHammurabi was not the first ruler to make laws.
- bBoth views are true.
- cMillions of visitors have looked up at it.
- dMany of the laws dealt with everyday life: wages, rent, trade, marriage, farming and debts.
- Why do you think it matters that laws are written down and made public?
- Are there any ways that laws today treat people differently? Should they?