Second Draft
Lucía's older brother tells her the truth about her contest essay, and she does not want to hear it. A grade 7 reading comprehension story with questions and an answer key.
- Cite several pieces of text evidence to support an analysis of a story RL.7.1
- Find a theme and show how it develops over the course of a story; summarize RL.7.2
- Explain how setting, characters and plot affect each other RL.7.3
- Explain how an author shows the points of view of different characters or narrators RL.7.6
Second Draft
Read the passage. Then turn the page and answer the questions.
Second Draft Story
Lucía finished her essay for the county writing contest at 11:42 on a Tuesday night, and she was sure it was the best thing she had ever written. It was about her grandmother's garden in Fresno, the rows of chiles and tomatoes, the morning she and Abuela had found a hummingbird nest no bigger than a walnut.
"Read it," she told her brother Mateo the next morning, holding out the pages. Mateo was in college. He wrote papers that were twenty pages long.
He read it twice. Then he said, "The hummingbird part is amazing."
Lucía waited.
"The first page is just a list," he said carefully. "Chiles, tomatoes, squash, beans. It doesn't sound like you. And the ending tells me what to feel. You don't need to. The nest already did that."
Lucía took the pages back so fast that one of them tore. "You don't even like gardens," she said, which wasn't the point, and they both knew it.
She did not speak to him for two days. On the third night, she reread the essay alone, trying to prove he was wrong. The first page was a list. The last paragraph said, "This taught me that small things can be beautiful," which suddenly sounded like a greeting card.
She started over at the nest. She cut the list down to one sentence, the smell of tomato leaves on her hands. She ended with Abuela's thumb, rough as bark, pointing at two eggs the size of jellybeans, and she left it there.
Lucía didn't win first place. She won third, which came with a ribbon and a certificate. She taped the certificate to Mateo's door with a note: "You were right. Don't let it go to your head."
Second Draft
Read the passage. Then answer the questions.
- aher brother's college
- ba writing contest she won
- cgrowing tomatoes for a farm
- dher grandmother's garden and a hummingbird nest
- athe hummingbird part
- bthe ending
- cthe title
- dthe list of vegetables
- ashe is hurt and wants to argue back
- bshe thinks he did not read it
- cit is the main problem with the essay
- dshe wants him to plant a garden
- ait was too short
- bit rhymed
- cit was a common, empty-sounding message
- dit was very creative
- ahonest feedback can be hard to hear but helps us grow
- bgardens are better than essays
- colder siblings are always right
- dcontests are unfair
Second Draft
Read the passage. Then answer the questions.