The Wrong Frog
The sign at Rosewood Middle School's creek says the frogs there are rare California red-legged frogs. Lena is pretty sure the sign is wrong. An original story for grade 7 (489 words) with numbered paragraphs, vocabulary notes, stop-and-think questions, text-dependent multiple choice, a two-part evidence question and a written response.
- Find a theme and show how it develops over the course of a story; summarize RL.7.2
- Explain how setting, characters and plot affect each other RL.7.3
- Find the meaning of words and phrases, including figurative language, and how sound and rhyme add meaning RL.7.4
- Analyze how a drama's or poem's form or structure adds to its meaning RL.7.5
The Wrong Frog
Read the passage. Then turn the page and answer the questions.
The Wrong Frog
For twenty years, the sign by the creek behind Rosewood Middle School had said the same thing: HOME OF THE CALIFORNIA RED-LEGGED FROG, A THREATENED SPECIES1. PLEASE STAY ON THE PATH. Every seventh grader learned about it. The school's mascot was even a frog.
Lena Park had been coming to the creek during lunch since September, sketching for her science notebook. By October, she had a problem. She had seen lots of frogs. None of them looked like the pictures of red-legged frogs in her field guide.
Red-legged frogs, the guide said, had pinkish-red undersides on their legs and a ridge of skin running down each side of their backs. The frogs in the creek were big and greenish, with no ridges at all. Their call wasn't the soft, stuttering grunt the guide described. It was a deep, booming sound, like someone blowing across the top of a bottle.
Lena knew that sound. She had looked it up. It was the call of the American bullfrog, a species that doesn't belong in California. Bullfrogs eat almost anything that fits in their mouths, including native2 frogs.
She brought her notebook to Mr. Haddad, her science teacher. He flipped through her drawings, frowning. "These are good sketches," he said. "But that sign has been there a long time. Experts put it up. Maybe the red-legged frogs are just harder to spot."
"Or maybe they're gone," Lena said.
Mr. Haddad didn't answer right away. Then he said, "If you think the sign is wrong, you'll need more than drawings. What evidence would convince someone who doesn't want to believe you?"
The Wrong Frog
Keep reading. Then turn the page and answer the questions.
The Wrong Frog (continued)
It became her project. For six weeks, Lena visited the creek three times a week. She recorded frog calls on her phone at dusk. She photographed every frog she could get close to, with a ruler in the picture for scale. She kept a spreadsheet: date, time, temperature, number of frogs, species. She never found a single red-legged frog.
Not everyone liked what she was doing. A girl on the student council told her she was ruining the school's frog. One of the PE teachers joked that she should leave the frogs alone and "let them be whatever they want to be." Some days, Lena wondered if she was wrong.
In December, Mr. Haddad helped her send her photos and recordings to a biologist3 at the county parks department. Two weeks later, the biologist came to the creek with a net and a clipboard. After an hour, she confirmed it. Every frog was a bullfrog. The red-legged frogs that the sign described had probably disappeared years ago.
The sign came down in January. A new one went up in the spring, with a photo Lena had taken. It explained what had happened and listed the work the county was planning to remove bullfrogs and bring back native frogs.
At the bottom, in small letters, it said: OBSERVATIONS BY LENA PARK, GRADE 7.
The Wrong Frog
Answer the questions. Use the text to help you.
- aSigns should never be trusted.
- bTeachers always believe their students.
- cBullfrogs are more interesting than other frogs.
- dCareful evidence can correct a belief that everyone has accepted for years.
- aIt pushes Lena to gather stronger, more convincing evidence.
- bIt shows that he has already contacted the county.
- cIt makes Lena angry at him.
- dIt convinces Lena to give up her idea.
- aTo help readers hear the difference between the two frogs' calls.
- bTo show that Lena is playing with bottles.
- cTo suggest that the creek is full of trash.
- dTo explain how frogs make noise with their mouths.
- aIt describes the new sign.
- bIt introduces the county biologist.
- cIt shows the social pressure Lena faces, which makes her persistence more meaningful.
- dIt explains how to identify a bullfrog.
The Wrong Frog
Answer the questions. Use the text to help you.
- apersistent
- btimid
- ccareless
- dboastful
- aThe school's mascot was even a frog.
- bFor six weeks, Lena visited the creek three times a week.
- cLena knew that sound.
- dSome days, Lena wondered if she was wrong.
The Wrong Frog
Answer the questions. Use the text to help you.
- Why do you think people get attached to beliefs like the school's frog?
- What would you have done if your evidence went against something everyone believed?