Worksheets

Arguing the Other Side

Amir is assigned to argue for a school rule he hates, and the research changes his mind about how to argue. A grade 8 reading comprehension story with questions and an answer key.

Grade 8 English
  • Cite the text evidence that most strongly supports an analysis of a story RL.8.1
  • Find a theme and analyze how it develops, including its relationship to characters, setting and plot; summarize RL.8.2
  • Analyze how dialogue or events move the plot, reveal character or lead to a decision RL.8.3
  • Explain how differences in what characters and readers know create suspense or humor RL.8.6
pigeonzacademyWorksheets
Name Date

Arguing the Other Side

Grade 8 English · Reading Comprehension Stories · Multiple choice + written

Read the passage. Then turn the page and answer the questions.

Arguing the Other Side Story

When Mr. Nguyen drew the debate topics from a hat, Amir got the worst possible one: "Middle schools should ban phones during the school day." Worse, he was assigned to argue for it.

"I'm against this," Amir said. "Completely."

"Perfect," said Mr. Nguyen. "Then you already know the strongest arguments you'll have to answer."

Amir started his research planning to do the minimum. He found an article saying phones distract students, and he wrote down "phones = distracting." Then he found a study from a school district that had tried a ban, and it was more complicated than he expected. Test scores had gone up a little. Fewer students reported being bullied online during the day. But some parents complained that they could not reach their children, and teachers said a few students hid phones anyway.

The more he read, the more annoyed Amir got, not because he was changing his mind, but because the other side was not as stupid as he had assumed. People who supported bans were not just old people who hated technology. Some of them were students who said they felt relieved to have a break.

On debate day, Amir did something he had never done before. He began by saying, "My opponents will tell you that families need to reach their kids in an emergency. They're right. So here's how a ban can still allow that." He explained the office phone system and a district that let students keep phones in lockers.

He lost the debate by one point. Afterward, his opponent, Clara, said, "You made my best argument before I could."

Amir still did not like the idea of a ban. But he understood it now, and he had learned that you cannot really beat an argument you refuse to understand.

RL.8.1 RL.8.2 RL.8.3 RL.8.6
Version 1001 · Page 1 of 3 · Free for classroom use · © 2026 Pigeonz Academy
Play more learning games
free at pigeonz.world
pigeonzacademyWorksheets
Name Date

Arguing the Other Side

Grade 8 English · Reading Comprehension Stories · Multiple choice + written

Read the passage. Then answer the questions.

1.
Why is Amir unhappy with his assignment?
  1. ahe has to debate alone
  2. bthe topic is too easy
  3. che lost the hat drawing
  4. dhe has to argue for a rule he disagrees with
2.
What does Mr. Nguyen mean by "Then you already know the strongest arguments you'll have to answer"?
  1. aAmir's own opinions are the counterarguments he must respond to
  2. bAmir doesn't need to research
  3. cthe debate is already decided
  4. dAmir should change sides
3.
What surprised Amir in his research?
  1. athe other side had more reasonable arguments than he expected
  2. bphones were not distracting at all
  3. ctest scores went down
  4. devery school bans phones
4.
How does Amir begin his debate speech?
  1. aby reading a list of facts
  2. bby attacking Clara
  3. cby admitting an opposing point and answering it
  4. dby telling a joke
5.
What is the theme of the story?
  1. ayou must understand an opposing view to argue well
  2. bteachers should let students pick sides
  3. cphone bans are always wrong
  4. dwinning debates is what matters most
RL.8.1 RL.8.2 RL.8.3 RL.8.6
Version 1001 · Page 2 of 3 · Free for classroom use · © 2026 Pigeonz Academy
Play more learning games
free at pigeonz.world
pigeonzacademyWorksheets
Name Date

Arguing the Other Side

Grade 8 English · Reading Comprehension Stories · Multiple choice + written

Read the passage. Then answer the questions.

6.
Describe one piece of evidence that supported a ban and one that argued against it.
For: test scores went up a little and fewer students reported online bullying. Against: parents couldn't reach their children and some students hid phones anyway.
7.
Why does Clara's comment show that Amir's new approach worked?
She says he made her best argument first, which means he answered the other side before she could use it, making his case stronger.