The Wall on Fifth Street
A neighborhood mural project turns into an argument about whose story the wall should tell. A grade 8 reading comprehension story with questions and an answer key.
- Cite the text evidence that most strongly supports an analysis of a story RL.8.1
- Find a theme and analyze how it develops, including its relationship to characters, setting and plot; summarize RL.8.2
- Analyze how dialogue or events move the plot, reveal character or lead to a decision RL.8.3
- Explain how differences in what characters and readers know create suspense or humor RL.8.6
The Wall on Fifth Street
Read the passage. Then turn the page and answer the questions.
The Wall on Fifth Street Story
The city gave the Fifth Street Community Center one wall, sixty feet long and twenty feet high, and three weeks to paint it. By the second meeting, the mural committee was at war.
The older members, led by Mr. Delgado, who had run the corner hardware store for forty years, wanted the mural to show the neighborhood's history: the old cannery, the streetcar line, the 1952 flood. The younger members, led by Imani Brooks, a high school junior with paint permanently under her fingernails, wanted to show the neighborhood now: the taco trucks, the skate park, the Vietnamese bakery, kids on bikes.
"Nobody even remembers the cannery," Imani said.
"That," said Mr. Delgado, "is exactly the problem."
Selena, who was thirteen and had joined mostly because her aunt made her, sat in the back drawing in her sketchbook. She drew the wall. She drew the cannery on the left side and the skate park on the right. Then, because the two halves looked like they belonged on separate walls, she drew a river running through both, the same river that had flooded in 1952 and that kids now rode their bikes beside. In the river she drew faces, old and young, reflected in the water.
Her aunt saw the sketch and held it up before Selena could stop her. The room went quiet.
Mr. Delgado studied it for a long time. "The river," he said slowly. "Everyone's been on that river."
Imani tilted her head. "We could paint the reflections from photos. Real people. Old photos and new ones."
They started painting the following Saturday. By the end, more than two hundred people had lent photographs, and the faces in the river went on for sixty feet.
The Wall on Fifth Street
Read the passage. Then answer the questions.
- awhat colors to use
- bwho should pay for the paint
- chow big the mural should be
- dwhether the mural should show the past or the present
- apeople forgetting the past is why the history should be painted
- bImani is not listening
- cthe mural is too small
- dthe cannery was a problem
- ait connects the old and new halves of the neighborhood
- bshe likes painting water
- cher aunt told her to
- dthe city required it
- aImani quits the committee
- bthe city cancels the mural
- ca design that combines both ideas wins over both sides
- dthe older members win the vote
- ait became a project the whole community shared
- bit showed only the past
- conly a few people liked it
- dit was never finished
The Wall on Fifth Street
Read the passage. Then answer the questions.