Breaker Boy, 1911
In the early 1900s, boys as young as eight worked in Pennsylvania coal breakers, picking rock out of the coal. This poem imagines one of them speaking. An original poem for grade 8 (192 words) with numbered stanzas, vocabulary notes, stop-and-think questions, text-dependent multiple choice, a two-part evidence question and a written response.
- Cite the text evidence that most strongly supports an analysis of a story RL.8.1
- Find a theme and analyze how it develops, including its relationship to characters, setting and plot; summarize RL.8.2
- Compare the structures of two or more texts and how each structure adds to meaning and style RL.8.5
- Explain how differences in what characters and readers know create suspense or humor RL.8.6
pigeonzacademyWorksheets
Name Date
Breaker Boy, 1911
Grade 8 English · Reading Library · Multiple choice + written · In the text
Read the passage. Then turn the page and answer the questions.
Breaker Boy, 1911
1
I sit on a plank above the chute1
with twenty boys in a row,
and the coal comes rattling down beneath us
like a black river that won't slow.
with twenty boys in a row,
and the coal comes rattling down beneath us
like a black river that won't slow.
2
We bend and pick the slate2 out,
the gray rock that won't burn.
It has sharp edges. By the end of the week,
our fingertips bleed. You learn.
the gray rock that won't burn.
It has sharp edges. By the end of the week,
our fingertips bleed. You learn.
3
The dust gets in our noses,
the dust gets in our throats.
The breaker3 boss walks up and down
with a stick, and nobody jokes.
the dust gets in our throats.
The breaker3 boss walks up and down
with a stick, and nobody jokes.
4
My brother sat here before me.
Now he's down in the mine.
The law says I'm too young for this.
I told the boss I'm twelve. I'm nine.
Now he's down in the mine.
The law says I'm too young for this.
I told the boss I'm twelve. I'm nine.
Stop and think What does the speaker reveal about his age, and why is it important?
He is nine but told the boss he was twelve, showing that children were working even though the law said they were too young.
1chute: a sloping channel that things slide down2slate: a gray rock found mixed with coal3breaker: a building where coal was crushed and sorted
pigeonzacademyWorksheets
Name Date
Breaker Boy, 1911
Grade 8 English · Reading Library · Multiple choice + written · In the text
Keep reading. Then turn the page and answer the questions.
Breaker Boy, 1911 (continued)
5
A man came last week with a camera
that stood on three legs like a deer.
He wrote our names and ages down
and asked how long we'd been here.
that stood on three legs like a deer.
He wrote our names and ages down
and asked how long we'd been here.
6
He said that people far away
would see us on the page,
and maybe they'd decide a boy
should be in school at my age.
would see us on the page,
and maybe they'd decide a boy
should be in school at my age.
7
I don't know if they'll see us.
I don't know if they'll care.
But I looked straight into his camera,
so they'll know that I was there.
I don't know if they'll care.
But I looked straight into his camera,
so they'll know that I was there.
Stop and think Why does the speaker look straight into the camera?
He wants people to know he was real and that he was there, even if he can't control what they do.
pigeonzacademyWorksheets
Name Date
Breaker Boy, 1911
Grade 8 English · Reading Library · Multiple choice + written · In the text
Answer the questions. Use the text to help you.
1.
Which statement best expresses a theme of the poem?
- aHard work always leads to wealth.
- bChildren enjoy working in coal mines.
- cCameras were common in 1911.
- dShowing people the truth can be a first step toward changing an injustice.
RL.8.2 The photographer hopes people will see the boys and decide they belong in school.
2.
In stanza 1, the coal is compared to "a black river that won't slow." What does this simile suggest?
- aThe work is endless and the boys cannot stop or rest.
- bThe boys enjoy watching the coal.
- cThe breaker is near a river.
- dThe coal is wet and cold.
RL.8.4 A river that won't slow suggests a constant flow of work.
3.
How does stanza 4 change the poem?
- aIt reveals that the speaker is only nine, which makes the poem more shocking and personal.
- bIt shows the speaker leaving the breaker.
- cIt introduces the photographer.
- dIt explains how coal is mined.
RL.8.5 The short final line, "I'm nine," lands with force after the details of the work.
4.
What can you infer about the speaker's future from stanza 4?
- aHe will become the breaker boss.
- bHe will go to school next year.
- cHe will probably go down into the mine like his brother.
- dHe will become a photographer.
RL.8.1 His brother moved from the breaker to the mine, suggesting the same path for him.
pigeonzacademyWorksheets
Name Date
Breaker Boy, 1911
Grade 8 English · Reading Library · Multiple choice + written · In the text
Answer the questions. Use the text to help you.
5.
Part A: How does the speaker feel about whether the photographs will make a difference?
- auncertain but determined to be seen
- bangry at the photographer
- ccertain that nothing will change
- dexcited and sure that he will be rescued
Part B: Which lines best support the answer to Part A?
- a"My brother sat here before me."
- b"I don't know if they'll care. / But I looked straight into his camera,"
- c"A man came last week with a camera / that stood on three legs like a deer."
- d"The dust gets in our noses,"
RL.8.6 He admits he doesn't know if people will care, but he still chooses to look into the camera.
6.
How does the poet use rhythm and rhyme to create a tone? Explain with two examples.
RL.8.4 Sample answer: Most stanzas rhyme the second and fourth lines, like "row" and "slow" or "burn" and "learn," which gives the poem a steady, repeating beat like the endless coal. The rhythm makes short lines like "You learn" and "I'm nine" hit hard. Together, they create a tone that is plain and serious, like a boy calmly stating hard facts.
Discussion questions
- Why might photographs have been more powerful than written reports in changing people's minds?
- What might a photographer today want people far away to see?