The Peppered Moth
When factory smoke blackened the trees of England, a light-colored moth turned dark in just a few decades. It became one of the clearest examples of natural selection. An original nonfiction text for grade 8 (401 words) with numbered paragraphs, vocabulary notes, stop-and-think questions, text-dependent multiple choice, a two-part evidence question and a written response.
- Find a central idea and analyze how it develops, including its relationship to supporting ideas; summarize RI.8.2
- Analyze how a text makes connections and distinctions between people, ideas or events RI.8.3
- Analyze the structure of a paragraph, including the role of particular sentences in developing an idea RI.8.5
- Trace and judge an argument; find irrelevant evidence RI.8.8
The Peppered Moth
Read the passage. Then turn the page and answer the questions.
The Peppered Moth
The peppered moth is a small, quiet insect that lives in the forests of Britain. It flies at night and spends the day resting on tree trunks and branches. For most of history, nearly all peppered moths looked the same: pale white wings sprinkled with black speckles, like pepper on salt. On trees covered in pale lichen1, they almost disappeared.
Every so often, though, a moth was born with a different appearance: almost completely black. This came from a change in a single gene2. Dark moths were rare, because a black moth on a pale trunk stood out to hungry birds and was quickly eaten.
Then came the Industrial Revolution. In the 1800s, factories in cities like Manchester burned enormous amounts of coal. Smoke and soot killed the pale lichen and coated tree trunks in black grime. Now the situation was reversed. Pale moths stood out against the dark bark. Dark moths blended in.
In 1848, a collector near Manchester recorded a dark peppered moth, the first ever written down. By 1895, about ninety-eight percent of the peppered moths near Manchester were dark. In less than fifty years, the population had changed.
The Peppered Moth
Keep reading. Then turn the page and answer the questions.
The Peppered Moth (continued)
This is an example of natural selection, the process Charles Darwin had described in 1859. Individuals in a population are not identical. When the environment changes, some traits help individuals survive and reproduce more than others. Those individuals pass their traits to their offspring3, and over generations, the helpful traits become more common. The moths did not choose to become dark, and no single moth changed color. The birds did the selecting.
In the 1950s, a scientist named Bernard Kettlewell released marked moths in polluted and clean woods and found that birds ate more of whichever color stood out. Some scientists later criticized parts of his methods. So between 2001 and 2007, a biologist named Michael Majerus carried out a larger and more careful experiment, releasing thousands of moths and watching birds eat them. His results confirmed that bird predation4 explained the change.
There was one more test. In the 1950s, Britain passed laws to reduce air pollution. As the air grew cleaner, lichen returned to the trees, and the bark grew lighter. Year by year, the dark moths became rarer, and the pale moths came back. Today, the pale form is common again. The peppered moth had shown natural selection working in both directions, within a human lifetime.
The Peppered Moth
Answer the questions. Use the text to help you.
- aCoal was used in factories, and Manchester was a large city.
- bLichen grows on trees, and birds fly at night.
- cDarwin wrote a book, and Kettlewell made mistakes.
- dPollution changed which moths survived, and this showed natural selection in action.
- aDark moths survived and reproduced more, passing on the trait.
- bFactories painted the moths black.
- cPale moths moved to other countries.
- dEach moth turned darker to hide.
- aBirds caused the change by eating the moths that were easiest to see.
- bBirds chose which moths to mate with.
- cBirds were selected by scientists for the experiment.
- dBirds carried dark moths to new places.
- aIt shows that the experiments were wrong.
- bIt explains how coal was burned.
- cIt shows the change reversed when the environment returned to normal, supporting the explanation.
- dIt introduces a new kind of moth.
The Peppered Moth
Answer the questions. Use the text to help you.
- aBy describing a later, more careful experiment that confirmed his conclusion.
- bBy saying Kettlewell's results were invented.
- cBy ignoring the criticism completely.
- dBy agreeing that natural selection did not happen.
- aToday, the pale form is common again.
- bHis results confirmed that bird predation explained the change.
- cSome scientists later criticized parts of his methods.
- dIn the 1950s, Britain passed laws to reduce air pollution.
- The author says the moths did not choose to become dark. Why is that an important point about natural selection?
- Can you think of other ways that human actions might change how animals evolve?