The Recount
Camila won the eighth-grade student council election by two votes. Then she finds five ballots no one counted. An original story for grade 8 (486 words) with numbered paragraphs, vocabulary notes, stop-and-think questions, text-dependent multiple choice, a two-part evidence question and a written response.
- Find a theme and analyze how it develops, including its relationship to characters, setting and plot; summarize RL.8.2
- Analyze how dialogue or events move the plot, reveal character or lead to a decision RL.8.3
- Compare the structures of two or more texts and how each structure adds to meaning and style RL.8.5
The Recount
Read the passage. Then turn the page and answer the questions.
The Recount
Camila Reyes won the election for eighth-grade class president by two votes: 141 to 139. When Ms. Chen read the results over the loudspeaker, Camila's friends screamed so loudly that the teacher next door came to check on them.
Her opponent1, Jonah Whitfield, shook her hand in the hallway afterward. "Congratulations," he said, and he sounded like he meant it, which somehow made it worse. Jonah had been class president in sixth and seventh grade. Everyone had expected him to win again.
The next morning, Camila volunteered to help Ms. Chen clean up the voting table in the library, partly to be helpful and partly because she still couldn't quite believe she had won. She was folding up the cardboard ballot box when something slid out from a gap in the bottom flap: five paper ballots, still folded, that had apparently been trapped there the entire time.
She unfolded them one by one. Jonah. Jonah. Camila. Jonah. Jonah.
She stood very still in the empty library. If these five counted, Jonah would have 143 votes and she would have 142. He would win by one.
Nobody had seen her. Ms. Chen was in the back office, and Camila realized that she could slip the ballots into her pocket without anyone ever finding out. She told herself it wasn't really cheating. She hadn't hidden them. The box had. And she had campaigned2 so hard: posters every weekend, a speech she had rehearsed dozens of times in front of her dog, and promises she genuinely intended to keep, like a quiet room for studying at lunch and a fix for the broken water fountains that had been out of order since September.
The Recount
Keep reading. Then turn the page and answer the questions.
The Recount (continued)
Then she thought about her speech. The line everyone had clapped for was this: "I'll always tell you the truth, even when it's hard."
She folded the five ballots back up and walked to the office.
Ms. Chen looked at the ballots for a long moment. "You know what this means," she said.
"I know."
The recount took fifteen minutes. That afternoon, Ms. Chen made a second announcement: due to a counting error, the final results were 143 votes for Jonah Whitfield and 142 for Camila Reyes. She did not say who had found the ballots. Camila had asked her not to.
Camila walked home slowly, taking the long way past the park. Her friends texted her furious messages about the ridiculous, unfair box, and she read every one of them without answering.
The next week, Jonah stopped her in the hallway. Somehow, he had found out. "Why did you turn them in?" he asked. "You could have kept them."
"Because then I wouldn't have deserved it," she said.
Jonah was quiet. Then he said, "I'm making a committee3 for the lunch study room idea. It was your idea, and it's a good one. Will you run it?"
Camila thought about it. Then she said yes.
The Recount
Answer the questions. Use the text to help you.
- aElections are always unfair.
- bHard work guarantees success.
- cFriends should support you no matter what.
- dIntegrity means doing the right thing even when it costs you something you want.
- aHis sincere congratulations make her feel uneasy about winning.
- bIt convinces her that he cheated.
- cIt makes her forget about the election.
- dIt makes her want to quit the election.
- aShe is looking for a way to avoid blame for keeping the ballots.
- bShe believes the box should be thrown away.
- cShe is proud of how she ran her campaign.
- dShe knows exactly who hid the ballots.
- aThey explain the rules of the election.
- bThey introduce new characters.
- cThey slow down key moments and build tension.
- dThey speed up the story so it ends sooner.
The Recount
Answer the questions. Use the text to help you.
- aHe respects Camila and values good ideas more than winning.
- bHe is still angry that the election was close.
- cHe feels guilty about winning and wants to quit.
- dHe wants Camila to do his work for him.
- a"Congratulations," he said, and he sounded like he meant it, which somehow made it worse.
- b"It was your idea, and it's a good one. Will you run it?"
- c"Why did you turn them in?" he asked.
- dSomehow, he had found out.
- Should Ms. Chen have announced who found the ballots? Why or why not?
- Was Camila's choice fair to the 142 students who voted for her? Explain.