Worksheets

Relevant or irrelevant evidence?

Decide whether each piece of evidence actually supports the claim.

Grade 8 English
  • Trace and judge an argument; find irrelevant evidence RI.8.8
  • Cite the text evidence that most strongly supports an analysis of an informational text RI.8.1

Loading practice…

Example: how to solve it

Read the claim and piece of evidence. Choose relevant if the evidence helps prove the claim, or irrelevant if it does not.

Ask: If this is true, does it give a reason to believe the claim?
Claim: Puzzle games can build problem-solving skills. Evidence: Many new video games cost more than $50.
irrelevant
  1. The claim is: Puzzle games can build problem-solving skills.

  2. Ask: if "Many new video games cost more than $50" is true, is that a reason to believe the claim?

  3. No. It may be true, but it has nothing to do with whether the claim is right, so it is irrelevant.

  4. Here it is solved: Claim: Puzzle games can build problem-solving skills. Evidence: Many new video games cost more than $50. → irrelevant