Worksheets

Relevant or irrelevant evidence?

Decide whether each piece of evidence actually supports the claim.

Grade 8 EnglishPractice online
  • Trace and judge an argument; find irrelevant evidence RI.8.8
  • Cite the text evidence that most strongly supports an analysis of an informational text RI.8.1
pigeonzacademyWorksheets
Name Date

Relevant or irrelevant evidence?

Grade 8 English · Reading Comprehension

Read each claim and piece of evidence. Circle relevant if the evidence helps prove the claim, or irrelevant if it does not.

Ask: If this is true, does it give a reason to believe the claim?
1.
Claim: Stores should stop giving out plastic bags. Evidence: Plastic bags can take hundreds of years to break down.
relevantirrelevant
2.
Claim: The city should build a skate park. Evidence: Skateboards come in many different colors.
relevantirrelevant
3.
Claim: Stores should stop giving out plastic bags. Evidence: Some grocery stores are open 24 hours a day.
relevantirrelevant
4.
Claim: Every classroom needs a recycling bin. Evidence: After one school added bins, its trash dropped by a third.
relevantirrelevant
5.
Claim: Puzzle games can build problem-solving skills. Evidence: In one study, students who played puzzle games got better at planning tasks.
relevantirrelevant
6.
Claim: Our school should start at 8:30 instead of 7:45. Evidence: Doctors say teenagers need 8 to 10 hours of sleep a night.
relevantirrelevant
7.
Claim: Every student should study a second language. Evidence: The word "language" has eight letters.
relevantirrelevant
8.
Claim: Puzzle games can build problem-solving skills. Evidence: Many new video games cost more than $50.
relevantirrelevant
9.
Claim: The library should stay open on weekends. Evidence: The library's carpet is blue.
relevantirrelevant
10.
Claim: Students should learn to cook at school. Evidence: My favorite food is spaghetti.
relevantirrelevant