Both Sides of the Press
New York City, July 1788. Hannah sets type in her father's print shop, where both sides of the Constitution debate get printed, and both sides come to dinner. An original story for grade 8 (504 words) with numbered paragraphs, vocabulary notes, stop-and-think questions, text-dependent multiple choice, a two-part evidence question and a written response.
- Find a theme and analyze how it develops, including its relationship to characters, setting and plot; summarize RL.8.2
- Analyze how dialogue or events move the plot, reveal character or lead to a decision RL.8.3
- Explain how differences in what characters and readers know create suspense or humor RL.8.6
Both Sides of the Press
Read the passage. Then turn the page and answer the questions.
Both Sides of the Press
Hannah Greer could set type1 faster than any apprentice2 on Water Street, and she was not an apprentice at all. She was the printer's daughter, and she had been picking tiny metal letters out of the type case since she was nine years old, laying them backward in a line, one by one, until a sentence formed.
That summer, every sentence was about the Constitution.
Her father printed whatever people paid him to print. On Monday it was an essay praising the new plan of government. On Tuesday it was a furious letter from a farmer upstate who called it a trap. "A printer's job is to keep the press open," her father liked to say. "Not to decide who gets to use it."
Hannah wasn't sure she agreed. Her older brother Daniel was a Federalist to his bones. He talked about trade, about debts, about how the country would split into thirteen squabbling3 pieces without a real government. Their Uncle Josiah, who farmed near Albany, was just as certain the other way. When he visited, the dinner table became a battlefield.
"You fought the king for eight years," Uncle Josiah said one night, jabbing his fork at Daniel, "and now you want to build a new one in New York City."
"A president isn't a king," Daniel snapped. "He's elected."
"Then show me where this Constitution protects my right to say what I'm saying now," Uncle Josiah said. "Show me the page."
Both Sides of the Press
Keep reading. Then turn the page and answer the questions.
Both Sides of the Press (continued)
Daniel opened his mouth and closed it again. Hannah, who had set every word of the Constitution in type when her father printed it, knew there was no such page.
On July 23rd, the city held an enormous parade in support of the Constitution, even though New York had not yet voted. Daniel marched with the shipbuilders, who rolled a model ship on wheels down Broadway. Hannah watched from the corner, her ink-stained hands in her pockets, and felt the crowd's excitement rise in her chest. Then she thought of her uncle's question and felt it fall again.
Three days later, the news came down the river from Poughkeepsie. New York had ratified, thirty votes to twenty-seven. But the convention had also sent along a long list of amendments it wanted added, rights it wanted written down in plain words.
That night, her father handed Hannah the list. "We print this tomorrow," he said.
She worked late into the evening, lamp burning, setting each right letter by letter: the freedom of the press, the right to a trial by jury, the freedom to worship. Backward in her hand, forward on the page.
When she finished, she pulled a proof4 and read it twice. Then she understood something her father had been trying to tell her for years. Daniel had won the vote. But Uncle Josiah's question was now printed in black ink for the whole city to see, and it was not going away.
A free press, she thought, did not mean one side won. It meant both sides kept talking.
Both Sides of the Press
Answer the questions. Use the text to help you.
- aOlder relatives are always right.
- bParades are the best way to change people's minds.
- cPrinting is easy work for young people.
- dA free press lets people keep debating, even after a vote is decided.
- aIt plants a question about missing rights that Hannah keeps thinking about until the end.
- bIt makes Daniel quit the Federalists.
- cIt convinces Hannah's father to stop printing.
- dIt causes Uncle Josiah to move to the city.
- aHard, careful work done out of sight can produce something clear for everyone.
- bHannah is making mistakes in her work.
- cThe page was printed upside down.
- dHannah wishes she were walking backward.
- aShe is too young to understand any of it.
- bShe only reads Federalist essays.
- cShe has read every word on both sides, so she sees the debate more fully than her brother or uncle.
- dShe knows nothing about the debate.
Both Sides of the Press
Answer the questions. Use the text to help you.
- aShe feels excited at first, then doubtful.
- bShe feels proud of her uncle the whole time.
- cShe feels bored, then angry.
- dShe feels afraid, then relieved.
- aThat night, her father handed Hannah the list.
- bThen she thought of her uncle's question and felt it fall again.
- cDaniel marched with the shipbuilders, who rolled a model ship on wheels down Broadway.
- dOn July 23rd, the city held an enormous parade in support of the Constitution, even though New York had not yet voted.
Both Sides of the Press
Answer the questions. Use the text to help you.
- Should a printer, or a website today, publish ideas it disagrees with? Why or why not?
- Why do you think the author made Hannah a printer rather than a voter?