The Fight Over the Constitution
In 1787, a new plan of government was written in Philadelphia. Then Americans spent almost a year arguing about whether to accept it. An original nonfiction text for grade 8 (430 words) with numbered paragraphs, vocabulary notes, stop-and-think questions, text-dependent multiple choice, a two-part evidence question and a written response.
- Find a central idea and analyze how it develops, including its relationship to supporting ideas; summarize RI.8.2
- Analyze how a text makes connections and distinctions between people, ideas or events RI.8.3
- Analyze the structure of a paragraph, including the role of particular sentences in developing an idea RI.8.5
- Find the author's point of view or purpose and how the author answers conflicting evidence RI.8.6
- Trace and judge an argument; find irrelevant evidence RI.8.8
The Fight Over the Constitution
Read the passage. Then turn the page and answer the questions.
The Fight Over the Constitution
In September 1787, after four months of closed-door meetings in Philadelphia, delegates1 to the Constitutional Convention signed a new plan of government. The plan, called the Constitution, would replace the Articles of Confederation, which had created a weak national government that could not collect taxes or settle quarrels between the states. But the Constitution was not yet law. It would take effect only after nine of the thirteen states ratified2, or approved, it.
Almost immediately, Americans split into two camps. Supporters of the Constitution called themselves Federalists. They argued that the country needed a stronger national government to pay its war debts, defend itself, and keep the states from falling apart into rival nations. In New York, three Federalists, Alexander Hamilton, James Madison and John Jay, wrote eighty-five newspaper essays defending the plan. They signed them with a single shared pen name3, Publius. The essays were later collected as The Federalist.
Opponents, who became known as Anti-Federalists, were just as passionate. Many were farmers and small-town leaders who had fought a war against a distant, powerful government only a few years before. They worried that a strong national government would swallow up the states, that the president might become like a king, and that a small Congress could not truly represent a huge country. Above all, they pointed out that the Constitution had no bill of rights. Nothing in it clearly protected freedom of speech, freedom of religion, or the right to a fair trial.
The Fight Over the Constitution
Keep reading. Then turn the page and answer the questions.
The Fight Over the Constitution (continued)
The debate filled newspapers, taverns and town meetings. Some states ratified quickly. Delaware was first, in December 1787, and several others soon followed. In other states, the vote was painfully close. In Massachusetts, Federalists won only after agreeing that the state would recommend amendments4, or changes, to protect individual rights.
In June 1788, New Hampshire became the ninth state to ratify, so the Constitution would take effect. But everyone knew that the new nation could hardly succeed without its two largest states, Virginia and New York. Virginia ratified days later. In New York, where many Anti-Federalists sat in the ratifying convention, the Constitution passed in July by just three votes, thirty to twenty-seven.
The Anti-Federalists lost the vote, but they did not lose the argument completely. In 1789, James Madison, now a member of the new Congress, proposed a list of amendments. Ten of them were ratified in 1791. Today, they are known as the Bill of Rights.
In a sense, both sides won. The Federalists got the stronger government they wanted. The Anti-Federalists got written protections for the rights they feared would be lost.
The Fight Over the Constitution
Answer the questions. Use the text to help you.
- aThe Constitution was accepted quickly and without argument.
- bDelaware was the most important state in the new nation.
- cNewspapers were the only way people shared news in 1787.
- dThe debate over ratifying the Constitution was intense, and both sides shaped the final result.
- aFederalists won there by promising to recommend amendments protecting rights, an idea that led to the Bill of Rights.
- bMassachusetts wrote the Bill of Rights by itself.
- cMassachusetts voted against any amendments.
- dMassachusetts refused to ratify until 1791.
- aThe national government would take over the states' power until they no longer mattered.
- bThe national government would buy land from the states.
- cThe states would join to form a new country.
- dThe states would grow larger.
- aTo show that New York ratified first.
- bTo explain how voting machines worked.
- cTo show how divided Americans were, even in one of the most important states.
- dTo prove that New York had the most people.
The Fight Over the Constitution
Answer the questions. Use the text to help you.
- aas people with serious, reasonable concerns
- bas a small group with no influence
- cas enemies of the country
- das people who did not care about government
- aIn June 1788, New Hampshire became the ninth state to ratify, so the Constitution would take effect.
- bThe Anti-Federalists lost the vote, but they did not lose the argument completely.
- cSome states ratified quickly.
- dThe essays were later collected as The Federalist.
- Which side's arguments do you find more convincing? Why?
- Why do you think it mattered that people argued so openly about the Constitution?